Monday, April 11, 2011

Some good reasons to go to school

In response to my post, Some Good Reasons Not to Go to School some of the commentors came back with “some good reasons to go to school.”  To give the other side of the argument equal attention, I am posting them here.  With my thoughts embedded.  I look forward to getting more comments on this important conversation.  


Six Reasons to go to school (Jeff Branzburg)*
  1. Most parents need to work – some multiple jobs – to earn a living; homeschooling is not an option.
    • The Innovative Educator:  In home educating families, it is not unusual for parent(s) to work.
  2. Some home situations are untenable – child abuse, lack of food, etc.; school can provide a welcome respite, be a source of support, provide breakfast and lunch, etc.

Sunday, April 10, 2011

Is your school like a prison?

I recently shared how so many of the freedoms we have in life are "Banned in School." In this post I ask you to consider the similarities between schools and prisons and then share your results. 





What are you doing to help students find their sentence?

Two questions that can change your life from Daniel Pink on Vimeo.

Saturday, April 9, 2011

What's Popular This Week on The Innovative Educator

Here’s the roundup of what's been popular on The Innovative Educator blog this week. Below you’ll see my top weekly posts along with the number of pageviews in the past 7 days.

This week the big winner was my follow up to The World's Simplest Social Media Policy.  The post was called World’s simplest online safety policy which I wrote in collaboration with Tom Whitby whose savvy, intellect, and ability to provide common sense advice helped turn this into a great article that will be helpful for innovative educators everywhere.  My ADHD remains in the top since it's been written.  The pharma companies spend millions to get kids hooked.  Find out why doctors, parents, and educators are clamoring to get you to do more research before drugging your children. The ten no nos for using an IWBs also finds it's way to the top again. Hope to have those no nos become less and less and more and more people read this post.  Another hit was "Are you smarter than a screenager."  Screenager-isn't that a great term? I didn't make it up, but it will certainly become a part of my vocabulary going forward.  Vickie's The Burden of Proof post received several provocative comments about a subject that still gives me nightmares...math!  Finally, perhaps the biggest news this week is the departure of our embattled school chancellor Cathie Black.  As I explain in this post, I won't be shedding any tears of this decision.

I hope there's something here that looks of interest to you.  If it does, check it out. If you’re so inspired leave a comment.


World’s simplest online safety policy
Apr 3, 2011, 10 comments 2,014 Pageviews
Cure ADHD without Drugs with These Resources from ...
Feb 5, 2011, 19 comments 913 Pageviews
Spend $0 on math resources and still get the best ...
Apr 4, 2011, 4 comments 860 Pageviews
Are you smarter than a screenager?
Apr 6, 2011, 2 comments 727 Pageviews
The World's Simplest Social Media Policy
Mar 27, 2011, 27 comments 714 Pageviews
Educators Need to Get Their Heads INTO The Clouds ...
Mar 29, 2011, 2 comments 657 Pageviews
The Burden of Proof
Apr 5, 2011, 15 comments 617 Pageviews
Tri State Ed Tech Conference - Post Conference Rea...
Oct 2, 2010, 2 comments 516 Pageviews
Former Chancellor Black Gets a Hands-On Lesson Abo...
Apr 7, 2011, 5 comments 399 Pageviews
The Ten No Nos of Teaching with a Projector or Interactive Whiteboard
May 10, 2010, 27 comments 233 Pageview









Friday, April 8, 2011

Some Good Reasons Not to Go to School

Wondering if home education might be a good option for your students or your own children? These Top reasons to homeschool or unschool provide some ideas to consider.
  • Children sent to school are away from home more then they are at home.
  • Compassion and kindness are not taught in schools.
  • Schools harbor drugs, violence, rape, sexism, racism, hate crimes, homophobia, religious persecution, depression, anxiety, and many more serious issues.
  • Learning does not occur in schools.
  • Many important subjects are not taught in schools.
  • In many public and private schools, art and creativity is not taught as an equal to academics, or as a means by which subjects can be taught to students.
  • Spirituality in general is not emphasized and if it is, it is generally a mainstream religion.
If you want to find out more about each, visit the original post from the Stavvick Family blog here. 

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Former Chancellor Black Gets a Hands-On Lesson About Educator Retention

In her New York 1 Interview earlier this year, the inexperienced, and now former, education chancellor Cathie Black had no empathy for educators who leave our system in droves.  Now that she’s one of them, perhaps, she’s learned an important lesson about those whose footsteps she is following in. Black clearly hadn’t done her homework last January before responding to New York 1 Reporter Errol Louis who asked if she was concerned about the appalling attrition rate of teachers in New York City where about 25% of leave within 3 years and that percentage doubles at the 5 year mark.

In an ever so cavalier response Black said this.
Teaching is a hard job. We want the ones who are committed. We want the ones who make a difference. We want the ones who want to work hard and really change the lives of these young people. They’re there on a mission. So, you know, some are going to leave.
It didn’t matter (or wasn’t worth investigating or even pondering) why these teachers left. To Black it was because they weren’t committed, didn’t want to work hard and  had no interest in changing the lives of young people. I thought of all the passionate, committed teachers like the one I recently wrote about here, who want to make a difference, but quit because they aren't able.  Perhaps if Cathie Black put in her time as her staff is required to do she would have understood that our teacher retention issue isn’t the result of weeding out the uncommitted teachers who have no interest in making a difference.  Rather those who leave are often our most qualified, like New York teacher of the year, John Taylor Gatto, who declared in his resignation published in the Wall Street Journal that he was no longer willing to hurt children.


The fact is that most teachers report they leave because of the lack of support, resources and dismal working conditions to which they are subjected (Alliance for Excellent Education). These teachers see no hope for change. Sadly, the best and brightest teachers are often the first to leave. (National Center for Education Statistics). What are left in many cases according to the Teacher Pathways Project Research Paper are the less-qualified teachers who are more likely to stay at a school than teachers with higher qualifications, “especially if they teach in low-achieving schools.”


Hopefully as she walks out the door today, the embattled Black will realize that the decision to leave the system is not as black & white as she once thought.  Now that her mission is over, and she joins the ranks of NYCs fallen educators, I wonder if she labels herself as someone wasn't committed, didn't want to want to make a difference and didn't care to change the lives of young people. 

You can visit the full interview complete with additional blunders and patronizing comments toward educators here.
Black explains why NYC schools are better off without those who resign.

Avoiding the Sorting Bins

(A post from Kate Fridkis, of Un-schooled and Eat the Damn Cake)

The people in the executive suites believed that the school existed to fulfill some socially productive process of information transmission– usually involving science projects on poster boards. But in reality, of course, high school is a machine for social sorting. The purpose of high school is to give young people a sense of where they fit into the social structure.
-David Brooks’ “The Social Animal.”


A machine for social sorting.
The image is striking. Let’s say for a moment that it’s true. It made me wonder, unsurprisingly, which chute would I have been funneled into if I had gone to school. Into which box would I eventually have been deposited?


Am I the artsy one?

Am I the put-together one?


Brooks describes how many distinct personalities people tend to have. People aren’t static, we’re fluid. We adapt instantaneously to different environments. People who can modulate more fluently are more popular. Sometimes I notice myself being awkward in situations I thought I’d mastered, or confident in situations I thought would leave me quivering and babbling. I interviewed an ex CIA operative a few weeks ago and was shockingly funny. I talked with a woman I’ve known for years and sounded like I’d just learned how to speak on Tuesday. The woman I’d known for years has seen me be incredibly awkward before. Maybe I still feel like a kid around her. All the CIA operative knew about me was that I work for AOL and have the ability (y’know, through my editor, of course) to get her a lot of publicity.


Am I the mischievous one?